An overview of assessing the quality of peer review reports of scientific articles
作者：
Highlights：
• Provides an understanding of the review report assessment of scientific articles.
• The state of the art of different techniques for assessing review reports.
• The common tools for report assessment are rating on a scale and the word analysis.
• The report assessment is a valid instrument for maintaining quality in the process.
• There is no consensus on quality criteria in the review report.
摘要
•Provides an understanding of the review report assessment of scientific articles.•The state of the art of different techniques for assessing review reports.•The common tools for report assessment are rating on a scale and the word analysis.•The report assessment is a valid instrument for maintaining quality in the process.•There is no consensus on quality criteria in the review report.
论文关键词：Systematic literature review,Peer review,Reviewers’ report assessment,Reviewers’ report quality
论文评审过程：Received 8 May 2018, Revised 9 July 2018, Accepted 12 July 2018, Available online 20 July 2018, Version of Record 20 March 2019.
论文官网地址：https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2018.07.002
