Generalization performance of support vector machines and neural networks in runoff modeling

摘要

Effective one-day lead runoff prediction is one of the significant aspects of successful water resources management in arid region. For instance, reservoir and hydropower systems call for real-time or on-line site-specific forecasting of the runoff. In this research, we present a new data-driven model called support vector machines (SVMs) based on structural risk minimization principle, which minimizes a bound on a generalized risk (error), as opposed to the empirical risk minimization principle exploited by conventional regression techniques (e.g. ANNs). Thus, this stat-of-the-art methodology for prediction combines excellent generalization property and sparse representation that lead SVMs to be a very promising forecasting method. Further, SVM makes use of a convex quadratic optimization problem; hence, the solution is always unique and globally optimal. To demonstrate the aforementioned forecasting capability of SVM, one-day lead stream flow of Bakhtiyari River in Iran was predicted using the local climate and rainfall data. Moreover, the results were compared with those of ANN and ANN integrated with genetic algorithms (ANN-GA) models. The improvements in root mean squared error (RMSE) and squared correlation coefficient (R2) by SVM over both ANN models indicate that the prediction accuracy of SVM is at least as good as that of those models, yet in some cases actually better, as well as forecasting of high-value discharges.