The problem of citation impact assessments for recent publication years in institutional evaluations

作者:

Highlights:

• Recent publication years cannot (should not) be included in a bibliometric analysis measuring citation impact.

• Using example data, the study presents various options for dealing with this problem in statistical analysis.

• One option is to show a line for citation impact regressed on ‘distant’ years showing the trend for ‘recent’ years.

• Another way of dealing with the problem is to work with the concept of samples and populations.

• The third option is the application of the counterfactual concept of causality.

摘要

•Recent publication years cannot (should not) be included in a bibliometric analysis measuring citation impact.•Using example data, the study presents various options for dealing with this problem in statistical analysis.•One option is to show a line for citation impact regressed on ‘distant’ years showing the trend for ‘recent’ years.•Another way of dealing with the problem is to work with the concept of samples and populations.•The third option is the application of the counterfactual concept of causality.

论文关键词:Bibliometrics,Percentiles,Citation window,Population,Sample,Counterfactual concept of causality

论文评审过程:Received 28 January 2013, Revised 15 May 2013, Accepted 15 May 2013, Available online 19 June 2013.

论文官网地址:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2013.05.002