Is the expertise of evaluation panels congruent with the research interests of the research groups: A quantitative approach based on barycenters

作者:

Highlights:

• We present methods to measure overlap of expertise in research evaluation.

• An entity's expertise can be summarized as its barycenter in cognitive space.

• Barycenters can be calculated in two or more dimensions.

• The distance between barycenters is an indicator of cognitive distance and hence expertise overlap.

• The method is applied to two research evaluations at the University of Antwerp.

摘要

•We present methods to measure overlap of expertise in research evaluation.•An entity's expertise can be summarized as its barycenter in cognitive space.•Barycenters can be calculated in two or more dimensions.•The distance between barycenters is an indicator of cognitive distance and hence expertise overlap.•The method is applied to two research evaluations at the University of Antwerp.

论文关键词:Research evaluation,Expert panel,Barycenter,Overlay map,Matching research expertise,Similarity matrix

论文评审过程:Received 8 December 2014, Revised 19 July 2015, Accepted 19 July 2015, Available online 2 September 2015, Version of Record 2 September 2015.

论文官网地址:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2015.07.009